• Inicio
  • Sobre Nós
  • Contacte-nos
  • Anúncios
  • Fórum
No Result
View All Result
Moz24h
  • Politica
  • Economia
  • Editorial
  • Cultura
  • Entrevista
  • Opiniao
  • Sociedade
  • Internacional
  • Desporto
MOZ24HORAS
  • Categorias
    • Economia
    • Desporto
    • Editorial
    • Politica
    • Internacional
    • Tecnologia
    • Sociedade
    • Entrevista
    • Cultura
  • Fórum
  • Anúncios
  • Contactos
  • Opinião
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Home Opiniao

Zimbabwe: SA’s tight corner

 South Africa is in a tight corner after last week’s election fraud by Zimbabwe’s ruling party, ZANU-PF.  

4 de setembro de 2023
in Opiniao
A A
0
Zimbabwe: SA’s tight corner

 Jonathan Katzenellenbogen

    Aug 30, 2023

 

For the first time ever, election observer missions from the Africa Union, AU, and the Southern African Development Community, SADC, have declared the Zimbabwean election a sham. This is a sea change, as in the past these missions have always endorsed the polls despite evidence of wrong-doing.

Pretoria hates the prospect of what the consequences of these reports could mean for a fellow liberation movement.

Adding to the growing political pressure not to recognise the election as free or fair, the UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres has pointed to the “the arrest of observers, reports of voter intimidation, threats of violence, harassment and coercion.”

According to the official body which oversees elections in the country, the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC), the incumbent President Emmerson Mnangagwa won with nearly 53 percent of vote against 44 percent for Nelson Chamisa, leader of the main opposition party, the Citizens Coalition for Change (CCC).

Yesterday the CCC demanded fresh elections and that the ZEC be disbanded. The party wants the AU and SADC to arrange and guarantee fresh flections as soon as possible. This places matters in SADC’s and the AU’s hands. If these two bodies stand by their election reports they will have an obligation to see to it that there are fresh elections.

The declarations of a fraudulent election by the AU and SADC missions were not the outcome that the ANC was expecting, and this now means Pretoria will have to give hard thought as to its options. If the SADC observers, who are from the region and cannot be accused of being colonial lackeys, say in their final report that the election was a fraud, then Mnangagwa cannot be recognised.

 

Prospect of non-recognition

South Africa and other regional leaders who might not want that will have to contort themselves to avoid the prospect of non-recognition. This might mean regional sanctions and a call for a re-run of the polls.

Might SADC member states aligned to Zimbabwe try to change the SADC final report on the polls?

That might not make much difference, as the world would notice if there was gross political interference with the report of the election observer mission. And besides, there is ample evidence of rigging before and on election day, as well as intimidation. With so many election observer teams pointing to widespread intimidation, official restrictions on the holding of rallies, a captured judiciary, the gerrymandering of constituencies, the late opening of polls in urban areas where the opposition has strength, and the shortage of ballot papers at these stations, there is enough evidence to suggest serious wrongdoing.

Then there was the gross disinformation that was part of this election. A flyer with the photo of Nelson Chamisa, the leader of the main opposition party, the Citizens Coalition for Change, calling for an election boycott was widely distributed in Harare and other urban areas. Chamisa has never called for a boycott.

The SADC report accused the Zimbabwean authorities of restricting access to the voters’ roll, the use of “intimidation” by what the reports calls a “quasi-security intelligence organisation”, called Forever Associates Zimbabwe, FAZ., and of  severely restricting the freedom of expression. The report of the polls says these did not comply with Zimbabwe’s Constitution, the country’s Electoral Act, or the SADC guidelines on democratic elections.

While it is a preliminary report, the SADC report is pretty comprehensive and probably hard to refute. And it is bolstered by similar assessments by other observer missions.

 

Personal grudge

ZANU-PF was quick to dismiss the SADC report as a reflection of a personal grudge by the observer teams, but that lacks credibility as most of the other missions said the same.

That means the region is now under pressure to act, and not recognise the results of the elections.

South Africa as the power broker may not want an election re-run. The deepest fear of the ANC is that an electoral loss by ZANU-PF will lead to its own loss of power. After all, big political changes often come in waves that are unstoppable. The exit of ZANU-PF  might create a precedent that opens new possibilities in the minds of voters here.

The ANC would be loath to use pressure such as sanctions against ZANU-PF. For years, in the face of questionable elections, Pretoria has maintained a policy of “quiet diplomacy”.

That is probably why out of hope that has turned into embarrassment, the ANC Secretary General, Fikile Mbalula, rushed to celebrate with ZANU-PF, over a supposed victory with a “viva President Emmerson Mnangagwa” on X, formerly Twitter. But then with most of the election observer teams in Zimbabwe saying the election was a sham, Mbalula backtracked and said what he meant was just “viva” and not congratulations.

Pretoria is now following a holding action on what to do about the Zimbabwe elections. Earlier this week the Presidency congratulated the Zimbabwe government on holding the elections, but took note of the criticisms of the observer missions.

One approach would be for SADC heads of state to urge ZANU-PF to form a coalition government. But these have not worked well in the past. The power-sharing arrangement in 2008 between the main opposition party at the time, the Movement for Democratic Change, and ZANU-PF was a means for the ruling party to stay in power and satisfy the region rather than a fair arrangement. ZANU-PF ran circles around the MDC.

 

A new urgency

With the election fraud and the continuing serious deterioration of the economy, there is now a new urgency over the Zimbabwe debacle. Countries in the region are worried about the prospects of instability and the fact that ZANU-PF is continuing to run the country into the ground, causing an increasing number of Zimbabweans to flee the country.

Despite its support of ZANU-PF, the ANC could find itself in a dilemma, says Mso Ndlovu, the spokesperson for the Zimbabwe African People’s Union, an opposition party.

The large influx of fleeing Zimbabweans into South Africa is placing mounting pressure on South Africa’s public services and fueling xenophobia, all of which could take away votes from the ANC. The only way to address the root cause of this is a turnaround of Zimbabwean economy, which is not about to happen under ZANU-PF.

The process of challenging the elections in court and SADC’s management of the Zimbabwe crisis could take time. The problem is that SADC heads could be more out to save ZANU-PF than the country.

Strong pressure from the US and Europe on SADC can also be expected. Much of the world is worried that if the election issue is not quickly resolved, Zimbabwe and the region could lurch toward instability with bad consequences. There is rising global concern, at least in the West, about the Wagner group’s widespread presence on the continent, and the insurgencies along the coast of East Africa.

One crisis tends to feed into others. Not dealing with this crisis with speed and resolve could ratchet up the costs for the region.

The views of the writer are not necessarily the views of the Daily Friend or the IRR

https://dailyfriend.co.za/2023/08/30/zimbabwe-sas-tight-corner/

 

Jonathan Katzenellenbogen

Jonathan Katzenellenbogen is a Johannesburg-based freelance financial journalist. His articles have appeared on DefenceWeb, Politicsweb, as well as in a number of overseas publications. Jonathan has also worked on Business Day and as a TV and radio reporter and newsreader.

Share14SendTweet9Share3Scan
Previous Post

Dois mortos em desabamento de mina no centro de Moçambique

Next Post

NGO launches study on Chinese mining impact on local communities

Related Posts

Por que as elites moçambicanas são rafeiras e grosseiras?
Opiniao

Por que as elites moçambicanas são rafeiras e grosseiras?

18 de setembro de 2023
390
Opiniao

Roque Silva, o sapato desatado e a sociedade de privilégios

19 de maio de 2023
335
Opiniao

“Biblioteca debaixo da Cidade”*

20 de abril de 2023
226

Deixe um comentário Cancelar resposta

O seu endereço de e-mail não será publicado. Campos obrigatórios são marcados com *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Estado moçambicano gastou 76 milhões com advogados desde 2019

3 de outubro de 2023
0
217

O ministro da Economia e Finanças moçambicano disse hoje que o Estado gastou cerca de 80 milhões de dólares (76...

Comandante da Polícia diz que multinacionais podem regressar a Cabo Delgado

Comandante da Polícia diz que multinacionais podem regressar a Cabo Delgado

3 de outubro de 2023
0
234

  Ramos Miguel   Analistas políticos consideram que ainda há muitos desafios mesmo em termos militares. Maputo — O comandante-geral...

Responsabilização dos bancos

Responsabilização dos bancos

3 de outubro de 2023
0
261

INTEGRITY-MOÇAMBIQUE, 02 de outubro de 2023-Enquanto as instituições responsáveis em prestar esclarecimentos sobre o que estará por detrás do mau...

“Feedbeck é crucial para um verdadeiro líder e para as organizações”

“Feedbeck é crucial para um verdadeiro líder e para as organizações”

3 de outubro de 2023
0
212

O Chairman do Grupo Intelec Holdings, Salimo Abdula, defendeu, recentemente, em Maputo, a adopção do modelo de comunicação de mão...

Facebook

Categorias

  • Cultura
  • Desporto
  • Economia
  • Entrevista
  • Internacional
  • Investigação
  • Opiniao
  • Politica
  • Sem categoria
  • Sociedade
MEDIALINE, LDA
Director :Estacio Valoi
Editores associados:Estacio Valoi e Luis Nhachote
Publicidade: Jordão José Cossa (84 53 63 773)
Cell: 844703860
Email: jordaocossa63@gmail.com, geral@moz24h.co.mz
NUIT: 400509905
Numero da entidade legal :100872250
Moz24horas Jornal Bilingue:
Endereço : MEDIALINE, LDA Rua do Tambo Tambulani Tambo, BA518 Nanhimbe Bº Eduardo Mondlane, Moçambique Pemba Cabo Delgado, 3202,
CONSULTORIA
Nr. 149 GABIFO/DEPC/2017/ MAPUTO,18 de Outubro
Mozambique

FICHA TÉCNICA
Director Editorial: Estacio Valoi / Redação: Germano de Sousa, Palmira Zunguze e Nazira Suleimane / Editores associados: Estacios Valoi e Luís Nhachote

© 2022 MOZ24H - Costumized by MOZAMOR COMERCIAL.

No Result
View All Result
  • Categorias
    • Economia
    • Desporto
    • Editorial
    • Politica
    • Internacional
    • Tecnologia
    • Sociedade
    • Entrevista
    • Cultura
  • Fórum
  • Anúncios
  • Contactos
  • Opinião
  • Login
  • Sign Up

FICHA TÉCNICA
Director Editorial: Estacio Valoi / Redação: Germano de Sousa, Palmira Zunguze e Nazira Suleimane / Editores associados: Estacios Valoi e Luís Nhachote

© 2022 MOZ24H - Costumized by MOZAMOR COMERCIAL.

Welcome Back!

OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

OR

Fill the forms below to register

*By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
error: Content is protected !!
Este website usa politicas de Cookie para saber mais click em Privacy and Cookie Policy.